I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, BYU got screwed by the College Football Playoff Committee and most national media members and college football fans finally realized that Saturday night when the Cougars took on Colorado in the Alamo Bowl.
Despite having a Top 10 resume the entire season, the Cougars — with two losses coming by a combined nine points and a team that was just 10 yards away from winning both of those games — the playoff committee did BYU dirty by dropping them 13 spots in those two down-to-the-wire losses.
The steep drop made sure the Cougars weren’t in the conversation for the final playoff spot as all the attention was given to SMU — a team that BYU beat on the road — and three SEC programs (Alabama, Ole Miss and South Carolina) that finished 9-3 and had a worse resume than BYU.
No. 17 BYU Crushes No. 23 Colorado 36-14 — Here’s All The Reactions
After Saturday night’s dominating 36-14 victory over No. 23 Colorado in the Alamo Bowl in front of a sellout crowd of more than 64,000, social media went off about how BYU was snubbed of the first-ever 12-team college football playoff.
This comes after all four first-round games in the playoffs were blowouts. Notre Dame beat Indiana (27-17) in a game that wasn’t even close as the Fighting Irish were up 27-3 with under two minutes to go in the game. Texas cruised past Clemson 38-24, Ohio State whipped Tennessee 42-17, and Penn State dominated SMU 38-10.
With Colorado coming in with Travis Hunter — the 2024 Heisman Trophy winner — and Sheduer Sanders, who is expected to be the No. 1 quarterback taken in the draft, all eyes were on the duo which are expected to go Top 3 in the NFL Draft next April.
With the game in primetime and with the entire country watching, BYU made sure to make a statement as it led from start to finish in the blowout victory.
ESPN Gets Slammed For One-Sided Coverage of BYU-Colorado Game
With such a dominant victory, the Cougars even had Shannon Sharpe and Chad “Ochocinco” Johnson singing their praises on their podcast about how much faster, stronger and tougher BYU looked against Colorado.
This led social media to ask questions as to why BYU wasn’t even mentioned in the College Football Playoff conversation, while other teams were: SMU, Ole Miss, Indiana and South Carolina.
While it’s the case of too little, too late, at least the Cougars got the opportunity to play in primetime against the biggest opponent — viewership wise — in games not involving the playoff. The Cougars certainly made the most of it as they had the entire country singing their praises and calling out the college football playoff committee.
While nobody will admit it, preseason rankings absolutely impact the playoff rankings and a preseason Top 15 ranking — which the Cougars will likely get next year — will put BYU in the final conversations for an at-large spot should the Cougars go 10-2 again. With so many starters coming back on both sides of the ball, BYU will be one of the favorites to win the Big 12 title next year.
Here’s all the reactions:
For the record, we don’t find it funny. https://t.co/E6bFZSwlSp
— BYU FOOTBALL (@BYUfootball) December 29, 2024
BYU not even getting a sniff of at-large consideration from the CFP committee past mid-November is far more damning than anything relating to Alabama, Ole Miss or South Carolina.
— Dean Straka (@DWStraka49) December 29, 2024
BYU got robbed of a playoff spot. Not Alabama pic.twitter.com/8EKOGt8RLD
— College Football Live (@CollegeFBonX) December 29, 2024
More serious CFP consideration???
BYU didn’t get any consideration despite having a Top 10 SOR ranking the entire year. Glad media members are finally paying attention. Too little, too late. #BYUvsCU #Big12FB #CFB #GoCougs https://t.co/RLn2QIkZdp
— Justin Giles (@JustinGiles_) December 29, 2024
Brigham shoulda been in the COLLEGE PLAYOFFS!!!! I don’t wanna hear about the bama argument … Indiana coach was too worried about talkin trash vs gettin his players ready to play… it was always and should have been BRIGHAM!! We shoulda beat Kansas but we thru a jump ball to a…
— Kyle Van Noy (@KVN_03) December 29, 2024
BYU is the playoff contender that might not have gotten its deserved consideration in the final weeks. Outstanding season for the Cougars, going 11-2 and beating SMU on the road.
— Pat Forde (@ByPatForde) December 29, 2024
The CFB Playoff committee did BYU dirty
— College Football Report (@CFBRep) December 29, 2024
That is easily one of the best 12 teams in the country.
1. They scheduled well & won on the road out of conference (won at the ACC champ)
2. They played 9 P4 league games
3. Lost 2 games by a combined 9 pointsAbsolute joke they weren't in the CFB Playoff. #BYU https://t.co/m0x1Qw8oGD
— Ryan McIntyre (@Moneyline_Mac) December 29, 2024
BYU should have been in the playoffs. Argue with a wall.
— Barstool Big12 (@BarstoolBig12) December 29, 2024
That’s one way to get some media attention 🤣 https://t.co/PRDvZ70jki
— Justin Giles (@JustinGiles_) December 29, 2024
It’s a crime that ESPN spent the entire lead up to the playoffs campaigning for bum ass 9-3 SEC teams to get in while 10-2 BYU, who held a road win against a playoff participant, didn’t get mentioned as a serious candidate at all
— Snyder's Windbreaker (@KSUWindbreaker) December 29, 2024
Before I go to bed, I'd be remiss to not say that #BYU was robbed of an at-large #CFP bid. pic.twitter.com/K6lsxQdD1F
— CowpokeU🤠🍊 (@cowpoke_u) December 29, 2024
I think it's pretty obvious now that BYU was absolutely shafted by the playoff committee.🤡🙃
— Chip Ormond (@COfrom_CO) December 29, 2024
Yep Aaron. Rest assured neither @BYUfootball or @CycloneFB will get the credit they deserve. Wrong times and Market sizes. Whose fault is that? Not theirs! https://t.co/CHfr2czctH
— Tim Brando (@TimBrando) December 29, 2024
— Derrico Henrio (@derrico_henrio) December 29, 2024
Said it weeks ago… BYU should have been picked to the playoff over SMU.
— Curtis Fitzpatrick (@cfitzfox) December 29, 2024
Remember, this BYU team beat SMU and had the same number of losses, but they weren’t even considered for the playoffs.
The CFP Committee including SMU in the playoff field this year over Bama, South Carolina, Ole Miss and BYU really was all-time bad.
— College Football Nerds (@CFBNerds) December 29, 2024
Follow Justin Giles on Twitter and Fan Insider on Facebook.
ESPN Gets Slammed For One-Sided Coverage of BYU-Colorado Game